In 1956 the Old Crossleyans won the Yorkshire Shield under the captaincy of Donald Whiteley and then again in 1958 under the captaincy of Colin Whitehouse.

The Crocs' greatest success was in 1960, when under the captaincy of Johnny Andrew, they won the Yorkshire Cup.

In 1988-89, the team registered a club record 24 straight victories and 2 years later in the 1990-91 season, the team were crowned champions of North One East Division One.