1995/96
1Q Hinckley Athletic A 1-3 Craig Brookes

1996/97
Pre Chester Le Street Town H 0-3

1997/98
Pre Whitley Bay 1-1 H Paul Kiely
PreR Whitley Bay 3-3 Steve Colclough, Paul Kiely and Craig Walklett (Whitley won 5-3 on penalties)

1998/99
Pre Sutton Coldfield Town A 1-2 Scott Dundas

1999/00
Pre Wellingborough Town A 0-3

2000/01
EP Pelsall Villa A 1-1 Chris Bermingham
EPR Pelsall Villa H 1-3 Rob Ratcliffe

2001/02
Pre Arnold Town A 1-4 Darren Twigg

2002/03
Pre Buxton H 4-1 Steve Tobin (2), Martin MacDonald and Danny Worthington
1Q Alfreton Town A 1-0 Darren Twigg
2Q Hinckley United A 0-3

2003/04
Pre Rugby United H 1-3 Darren Twigg

2004/05
Pre Newcastle Town 1-4 Matt Rhead

2005/06
Pre Stourbridge A 2-2 Julian Ward, Glyn Hancock
PreR Stourbridge H 5-2 Adam Vickers, Matt Rhead, Julian Ward, Wayne Johnson, Glyn Hancock
1Q Leamington H 0-1

2006/07
Pre Spalding United H 2-0 Ian Dawes, Matt Rhead
1Q Leek Town H 0-0
1QR Leek Town A 1-0 Michael Lennon
2Q Rothwell Town H 6-0 Matt Rhead (3), Michael Lennon (3)
3Q Haverhill Rovers A 1-2 Aaron Rey

2007/08
Pre Oldbury United A 3-1 Phil Hadland, Michael Lennon 2
1Q Willenhall Town H 2-0 Craig Lovatt, Michael Lennon
2Q Rainworth Miners Welfare A 0-2

2008/09
Pre Pilkington XXX H 3-0 Jimmy McCarthy, Tom Moss, Andy Matthews
1Q Eastwood Town A 0-4

2009/10
Pre Alvechurch H 1-0 Dave Walkers
1Q AFC Wulfrunians H 2-3 Ricky Bridge, Matt Haddrell

2010/11
Pre Biddulph Victoria H 0-0
PreR Biddulph Victoria A 4-0 Dave Walker (2), Nick Ward, Tim Sanders
1Q Chasetown H 3-0 Dave Walker, Liam Shotton, Adam Beasley
2Q Solihull Moors A 0-2

2011/12
Pre Atherstone Town H 5-1 Dave Walker, Nick Ward, Mark Beeston, Andy Kinsey (2)
1Q Gornal Athletic H 3-0 Dave Walker (2), Steve Branna
2Q Boston United A 0-0
2QR Boston United H 2-0 Sam Hall, Craig Dove
3Q Long Buckby H 2-1 Andy Kinsey, Mark Beeston
4Q Bradford (Park Avenue) 0-2

2012/13
Pre AFC Wulfrunians A 0-1

2013/14
Pre Market Drayton Town A 3-1 Tom Urwin (2), Matt Haddrell
1Q Tipton Town A 0-2

2014/15
Pe Evesham United A 1-3 Joe Woolley

2015/16
Pre Westfields 1-1 A Anthony Malbon
PreR Westfields H 5-6 Ross Davidson, Andy Kinsey (2), Anthony Malbon (2)

2016/17
Pre Lye Town H 2-0 David Artell, Harry Clayton
1Q Stafford Rangers A 2-1 Anthony Malbon (2)
2Q Matlock Town H 1-2 Anthony Malbon

2017/18
Pre Trafford A 2-2 Lee Cropper, Anthony Malbon
PreR Trafford H 2-0 Lee Cropper, Anthony Malbon
1Q Clitheroe H 3-2 Ryan Austin, Anthony Malbon (2)
2Q Kettering Town A 0-2

2018/19
Pre Ramsbottom United H 1-1 Anthony Malbon
PreR Ramsbottom United A 0-0 Kidsgrove won 3-2 on penalties
1Q Atherton Collieries A 2-1 Lee Williamson, Shaun Rhodes
2Q Mossley A 2-1 Kyle Diskin, Anthony Malbon
3Q Workington A 0-0
3QR Workington H 2-1 Lewis Bergin, Rumineo
4Q Hartlepool United A 0-1

2019/20
Pre Newcastle Town H 1-1 Anthony Malbon
PreR Newcastle Town A 2-1 Lewis Bergin, Jim O’Neill
1Q Cleethorpes Town H 2-1 Ruben Wiggins-Thomas (2)
2Q Matlock Town A 2-1 Anthony Malbon, Kingsley Adu-Gyamfi
3Q Gateshead H 0-1

2020/21
Pre Chasetown H 0-1

2021/22
Pre Bedworth United A 1-2 Kyle Diskin