2002/03
R1 Frickley Athletic H 1-1
R1R Frickley Athletic A 1-2

2003/04
Pre Guiseley A 1-7

2004/05
Pre AFC Telford United H 4-2
R1 Bishop Auckland A 3-2
R2 Vauxhall Motors H 1-2

2005/06
1Q- Ashton United H 3-1
2Q Gateshead A 0-1 Gateshead were removed for fielding an ineligible player
3Q- Warrington Town A 0-4

2006/07
Pre Goole Town A 0-0
PreR Goole Town H 3-2
1Q Harrogate Railway Atheltic H 2-1
2Q Chasetown H 0-0
2QR Chasetown A 1-1 Chasetown won 4-3 on penalties

2007/08
Pre Chasetown H 0-1

2008/09
Pre Retford United A 2-1
1Q Boston United A 0-6

2009/10
Pre Leek Town H 0-1

2010/11
Pre Mossley A 1-1
PreR Mossley H 1-4

2011/12
Pre Loughborough Dynamo H 2-1
1Q Daventry Town A 3-4

2012/13
Pre Daventry Town H 4-1
1Q Stamford A 1-3

2013/14
Pre Bedworth United H 3-1
1Q Curzon Ashton H 0-4

2014/15
Pre Loughborough Dynamo A 3-6

2015/16
Pre Loughborough Dynamo A 3-0
1Q Newcastle Town A 2-2
1QR Newcastle Town H 3-0
2Q Marine A 2-2
2QR Marine H 0-1

2016/17
1Q Soham Town Rangers H 5-3
2Q Stocksbridge Park Steels H 3-5

2017/18
Pre AFC Rushden & Diamonds A 3-1
1Q Newcastle Town A 2-2
1QR Newcastle Town H 2-1
2Q Grantham Town H 0-2

2018/19
EP Coleshill Town A 2-1
Pre Wisbech Town A 2-1 Tie awarded to Wisbech Town

2019/20
EP Daventry Town A 1-1
EPR Daventry Town H 2-0
Pre Wisbech Town H 1-0
1Q Colne H 0-1

2020/21
1Q Cambridge City A 3-2
2Q Daventry Town A 2-0
3Q Stratford Town A 3-1
R1 Stamford H 0-2

2021/22
1Q Evesham United H 4-1
2Q Carlton Town A 2-2 Carlton won 4-3 on penatlies